Witch Of Mystery Book Reviews

Category: Mystery

  • The Cat of Amontillado by SM Reine

    The Cat of Amontillado Author: SM Rein 5 out of 5 Stars The Haven is a retirement community for magical and immortal beings. Two of its residents are Izzy, a zombie, and Suzy, an angel, who one day rescue a group of kittens from under their porch. They end up keeping one who they name…

  • A Knead to Kill by Chelsea Thomas

    A Knead to Kill Author: Chelsea Thomas 4.5 out of 5 Stars After successfully solving a murder in their hometown, Chelsea, Miss May, and Teeny head to Chester, Vermont to participate in the Vermont Bake-Off. And excitingly, the judge is going to be famous baker George Rivers. Soon after checking in to their hotel, Chelsea…

  • A Study in Stone by Michael Campling

    A Study in Stone: A British Mystery (The Devonshire Mysteries prequel) Author: Michael Campling 4 out of 5 stars Update: This book has been rewritten and expanded into a full novel, which I’ve written a new review for here: https://www.witchofmysteryreviews.com/2025/11/29/a-study-in-stone-by-michael-campling-2/ Needing a break from corporate life in London, Dan agrees to house sit for his…

  • Risky Relics by E. Z. Pennington

    Risky Relics (Rose Hollow Mysteries Book 1) Author: E. Z. Pennington 2.5 out of 5 stars After her Aunt Pauline’s disappearance, Becky Olson is given ownership of her antique store and in Rose Hollow, Maine. Three weeks after arriving in town, Becky is slowly beginning to get used to the small town and has made…

  • Scraps of Paper by Kathryn Meyer Griffith

    Scraps of Paper (Spookie Town Murder Mysteries Book 1) Author: Kathryn Meyer Griffith 4 out of 5 stars After her husband’s death, Abigail Sutton decides to start fresh by moving to the small town of Spookie. She also hopes to fulfill her dream of being a freelance artist. She buys a small home and begins…

  • A Sight for Psychic Eyes by Kelly Hashway

    A Sight for Psychic Eyes (Piper Ashwell Psychic P.I. prequel) Author: Kelly Hashway 4.5 out of 5 stars Piper Ashwell is psychic, and she uses her visions as a private investigator. She also helps the police, including her father who is a detective. When a 9-year-old boy named Eric goes missing in the middle of…

  • The Mirrors by E. F. Townsend

    The Mirrors (Tori Hartley Mystery Book 1) Author: E. F. Townsend 3.5 out of 5 stars Tori Hartley is an antique dealer who lives in the Old Louisville neighborhood in Louisville, Kentucky. Along with her own small home, she also owns a large mansion that she rents out. When her renter, Scott, goes missing, Tori…

  • Crimes of Magic by Richard King

    Crimes of Magic: The Witch’s Artifact (Crimes of Magic Book 1) Author: Richard L. King 4 out of 5 stars When P. I. Rachel Chase invites her friend, Robert Walker, to join her on a case, he thinks he knows what to expect. But neither he nor Rachel expect the simple case of suspected adultery…

  • The Owl and the Dragon by R.A. Nargi

    The Owl and the Dragon (The Bander Adventures Book 1) Author: R.A. Nargi 5 out of 5 stars After being attacked on the road and most of his possessions stolen, Bander finds his way to Hytwen. Hytwen is a small village on a lake, and across the lake is the village of Ortwen. Both villages…

  • The Art & Craft of Murder by Cozy Cat Parker

    The Art & Craft of Murder (Whistler’s Cove Cozy Mysteries Series Book 1) Author: Cozy Cat Parker 5 out of 5 stars Misty Williams runs a tea house in Whistler’s Cove, a coastal, artist community. One day, the owner of the town’s art gallery, Hilary Short, is poisoned and dies in the tea house. Misty…